eHarmony Relationship Advice

Dating and relationship advice you can really believe in.

25 February 2011

What women – and men – really want

by eHarmony

We've delved into the top 10 Must Haves and Can't Stands of our male and female eHarmony members, to find out what the sexes really want. You might be surprised!

Men want...to love and be loved

Picture 1 of 8

The fact is that we all want to love and to be loved, but surprisingly men rate this even more highly than women. When choosing their Top 10 Must Haves and Can’t Stands men rank I want to ‘feel deeply in love with and attracted to my partner’ and I want someone ‘who’s gentle and kind’ higher than women do.

VN:F [1.9.20_1166]
Rating: 7.0/10 (42 votes cast)
What women - and men - really want, 7.0 out of 10 based on 42 ratings

Comments

1

Olgas Daughter

26 February 2011 10:39

This comment will really make some people angry but I’m going to say it anyway. What I find so incredibly arrogant (or plain stupid) and mystifying is that the most unattractive, overweight and cerebrally challenged men want and believe they can get, beautiful, slender bright women! It’s never going to happen………..

2

David

5 March 2011 13:02

@Olgas Daughter

You can never say never, I have seen (and know personally) very overweight men who have very attractive and thin wifes.

Just because you obviously dont seem to find larger men attractive does not mean that no woman in the country is going to!

All I can say is you must have a huge amount of books at home if you have been reading them all just by looking at the cover.

3

Grochnev

13 March 2011 01:57

I have also seen slender-bodied men married to or in love with overweight woman. Although the generally conditioned mindset of shallow folk think in terms of birds of a feather, the “beautiful people” don’t have a monopoly on happiness. It takes more than appearances and money to keep a relationship together, and if a couple appear to be mismatched in appearances, the chances are their relationship is on solid love ground.

4

Luke

14 March 2011 02:27

It’s an extreme rarity that any good looking man or women will date the opposite in terms of looks. There will usually be some other ulterior motive.

Every relationship I know bar one, it’s like for like. Either both look the business, or both look like horses or giant jellies!

I for e.g. am not the best looker in the world, despite working out and getting a healthy lifestyle. I can’t do enough about my face to make it desirable to women and unless I can shift this belly fat off, the improvements to my upper body and legs will mean nothing.

5

Mel

14 March 2011 07:49

I think you are all missing the point here. The article says men want to feel “deeply in love with and attracted to their partner” not “they want to have a thin conventionally attractive partner” whether the woman is fat or thin etc doesnt matter so long as there is chemistry and spark. Different people find different things attractive.

6

Petra

14 March 2011 13:35

Im just wondering if Olga’s daughter classes herself as the beautiful one?

AND women can be attracted to opposites. Many larger men can seem very attractive as long as they have confidence and show ambition.

Fat slobs in dirty vests, burping and watching footie are a total turn off, but then a slim, handsome bloke doing the same thing would also be.

7

Charles Evans

14 March 2011 15:07

I am short 5′ 4″ and overweight, but I must say that I have never had much problem ‘getting the girl’. I suppose that is because I am highly intelligent, very witty, don’t go too far out of my league, and speak some of this foreign language known only to the female of the species. Plus, of course, looks aren’t everything. Some women really like chubby men.

8

Val

14 March 2011 19:35

I think I know what Olgas Daughter means and yes there are always exceptions to the rule. Basically women pay a lot more attention to themselves and will make the most of what they look like – especially before a first date, whereas men make little effort and feel us women should just accept them for themselves. Maybe they have a point, but they’d be seriously disappointed if we turned up without doing anything with our hair, without shaving or half-cut! I agree with her generalisation – men think they deserve to find someone who ticks all their boxes (including age) even though they’re not prepared to put any effort in themselves. Older men tend to want younger women, but seem oblivious to the fact that, if they’ve let themselves go, they might have to settle for someone their own age! I wish I knew where their self-confidence comes from!

9

Sydney

14 March 2011 21:28

I think being attractive can be a problem for either sex – it’s something that’s hard to see beyond sometimes, especially for men (sorry guys!) It’s such a powerful and important part of relationships, but it’s not everything.

10

Luke

14 March 2011 22:33

Usually the insane ones. Can’t remember the last attractive girl I’ve seen with a fat bloke. Gorgeous with gorgeous, ugly with ugly.

11

ni

16 March 2011 20:04

Frankly, very bemused, those older guys chasing younger ladies, hey only one thing on there mind.I sincerely find the ladies my age far more intriguing than the younger version due to the changing in social dynamics as quite a few are deeply concerned about looks, health,due to changing times. Give me a late 30′s or early forties anyday. PS I am not overweight

12

Rich

18 March 2011 15:07

To say its never going to happen is a rather bemusing statement to say the least.Even though its sad to admit,if the “ugly” “arrogant”guy in question has enough wealth and power anything is possible.Bernie Ecclestone..Sven..Billy Joel…Lembit Opik…Chris Evans..the list is endless

13

nita

19 March 2011 18:42

Well, I’m with Olga’s daughter. Unattractive and/or dense men just don’t cut it for me, even with the alleged power of Chris Evans and his ilk. To be blunt, yes, I am attractive, solvent and not lacking in brains. I have been amazed by the numbers of utterly incoherent munters who seem to think I might be even slightly interested in them. Get real and punch within your weight. If you think my comment is arrogant, and I’m sure there will be many who do, that’s unfortunate. Maybe you feel that way because you know you’re trying to play outside your league….

14

Onmyowntwo

21 March 2011 15:03

Nita, Nicely put. Same here.

15

Kath

22 March 2011 23:49

Nita, I second that too – also consider myself to be attractive, intelligent and solvent (without that sounding like a brag)! But I do think, from my own personal observations over the years, that there are more attractive women with minger men, the simple reason being that women are often more open-minded and are prepared to look beyond the physical appearance, but I have truly never seen or known a gorgeous guy with a fat/ugly/old/whatever female, it just doesn’t happen – they can’t see further than the face/body, being, ahem, more shallow in their general outlook. Apologies if this offends but I’ve long thought this, it is merely an observation.

16

Andrew

26 March 2011 10:19

I love these sweeping generalisations! I’m a 40 year old man with a genius level IQ (MENSA and otherwise tested) who also has a medical condition that makes it very easy to gain weight, so I am in the middle-aged, overweight and balding category.

For me, brain is always more important than body. Vanity (which is something that frequently comes with good looks in both genders) is a more unattractive trait than simply being unattractive. When I’m looking at a profile it’s usually possible to tell if the person has a brain ticking away. When I enter into communication with the interesting ones I try to appeal to that intelligence, and usually that is successful. I’ve had dates with many women, ranging from very unattractive to beautiful, but so far none of them have been mentally compatible. I know that my own weight has been an issue for three of them (two on the less attractive side, one in the more attractive side).

If you’re one of the attractive ones, don’t think that beauty is everything, because it isn’t. You’d have to be quite shallow to believe that it is, and likewise to believe that beauty is all that anyone else is looking for.

Hint to the ladies (and probably the men but I never see those profiles) – you’ve spent your time filling in the long list of questions just to get to the profile stage, so spend a few minutes to actually fill the profile out fully… and try to be more original than “likes going out and staying in, spending time with family and friends, and travelling. Everyone likes those things, and if that’s all you have on the profile, you’re heading for the archive bin no matter what you look like.

17

Eve

26 March 2011 10:38

I actually find the some of the comments on here morally depraved. Anyone with any tact or social grace would not be saying such cruel things.

18

Liz

26 March 2011 20:31

Eve, so elegantly put and I totally agree with you.

19

Neil

28 March 2011 00:01

Perhaps, many men have preconceptions that no women are really that financially irresponsible, whereas many women might have the preconception that many men can be financially irresponsible. It would be silly to put something as a “must have” or “can’t stand” when you think your partner is higly unlikely to not have / have that quality.

20

O

28 March 2011 21:39

Hey guys. Stop all this bitterness! Men against women, and women against men. I though this was supposed to be a dating site!

21

Teresa

8 April 2011 23:35

well from experience i can say i have been on both ends of the scales.In 1986 i wieghted 15st.i was never asked out on dates ,never asked to up to dance.Than i dieted and lost 7st in just under a year and recieved 3 marriage proposels and a lot of dates.It,s a sad fact i was treated so different just because i lost weight.I maintained my weight until 1999 than i started to gain weight after i gave up smoking on the 18th march 1999.I am now 17st and acourse no dates in 10 years not even via dating agency as you guys take one look at my attractive young looking fat smiley face and don,t want to know well that won,t be for long because i am dieting again and i will be slim by christmas but i won,t be bothering with any dating agency as i won,t be needing one.I know that for a fact.

22

Klaus

20 April 2011 07:13

Men vs. women. No good. We are not THAT different. Just show honest interest and affection for the other sex! Older men want younger women, of course they do because many women just lose it when settled in routines like marriage and sitting down before the telly munching all the yummies and enjoy their wine. Men want to feel enthusiastic about their wives. Looks are not most important but can indicate a degree of carelessness. Men also can fall into that league but have more confidence than many women. Women want to be loved and understood and spoiled, men give it to them and often get ripped off. Who is worse? Women or men? Both can be. Just look at the bright side and look beyound what you expect to see and you will find love.

23

phil

20 April 2011 07:56

I find being rich helps find that tall slim younger eyecandy even if you are fat bald and old.Not that women are shallow of course but bling does seem to have some appeal,Deny it and I’ll believe you!Oh yes there is one other thing.. sitting in the corner alone and licking my eyebrows helps too

24

"eyecandy"

20 April 2011 18:38

hmm… am I the only “lucky” girl who keeps meeting tall, dark, attractive, rich, kind and considerate men?!? I guess I am judging by the above! Although I must add: first things I go for in a man is cleanliness, smart dress sense (a man who buys cheap clothes lacks self-respect, and that says a lot about everything else!), and confidence without being an arrogant arse! Oh yeah, a nice scent of an expensive aftershave is a MUST!

25

Teresa

21 April 2011 18:29

o yes i agree eye candy sexy smelling expensive aftershave is the best thing any man can wear.

26

viv

22 June 2011 22:54

frightening stuff guys, suppose we’re all animals at the end of the day?

27

Phil

24 June 2011 09:53

I agree with the exceptions people mention above but mostly I think that both men and women are motivated by the same need. That need is stress-reduction. Men and women generally have a very different path to achieving it.
Men need sex to reduce stress. To accomplish that men need to be attracted to their mate (not overweight),want to love and be loved(=sex),want a calm-risk taker(won’t raise his stress level),want her to explore sexual desires(more sex). All these being met, results in massive stress reduction for a man.
Women need security (money) which will reduce her stress. To accomplish this they need him not to be angry (he might leave her-no security),not a couch potato(he’s not making money watching tv), he’s to be financially responsible because how else is he going to support the finances and provide security and not throw it away on the horses etc.

28

Teresa

26 June 2011 23:00

oh what tosh phil you sound just like a ex of mine who use to think that sex is the glue of the relationship,which is tosh too ,respect and trust is the glue of a relationship and i actually felt insulted when you said that women rely on men for finances that not been the case in my experience as all my ex,s have been out of work and it,s been ME! that have supported them and i am still helping my son out of debt so that he won,t lose his flat and by the way i am not well of far from it.

29

Southern Steve

6 July 2011 06:05

Going back to the earlier comments reference weight, barring a medical condition being obese or considerably overweight tells the world and opposite sex a couple of things:

1. Your persnal health is not that important to you.

2. You may be percieved as lazy and lacking in confidence.

3. You clearly dont respect yourself, so why should other people respect you?

Sorry to be blunt but wake up and smell the coffee! Humans are geared to make very quick judgements when looking at strangers, its part of our DNA and is biologically hard wired – similar to the fight or flight responce.

So, stop justifying being overweight and pretending its great or its all about intellect, try losing a few pounds, I bset you will be amazed with the results.

30

Teresa

7 July 2011 11:20

southern steve -what about smokers ? what about achololics? what about drug addicts? are you going to attack them over the internet i think not!is it only fat people you hate? before you throw your toys out of the pram grow up! we are have faults and failures.there are people out there doing far worst than just injoying their food and not chewing on a lettuce leaf and patronizering others like you are doing and one last thing FAT I AM BUT LAZY FAR FROM IT!

31

kacki

10 July 2011 10:50

You are all talking some sense.However men are selfsigh, self-righteous and arrogrant. Women are too needy, and dependent on the opposite sex. Women in general need to take ownership of themselves, thier lives, happiness, finance, and general well-being. Enjoy life as an independent soul, and someone who derserves you will love you for who you are. Another thing relationships take compromise from bth partners. There are too many BOYs you expect their ladies to be their MOTHER. You all need to get over that fact. I know a guy called YSEN , who is a complete arse whole,who is emotionally weak, in mind, and spirit, and his only achievement will be marrying his cousin , since his religion allows it.

32

Teresa

16 July 2011 09:44

this is one woman [me] who is most definely not needed of men .I have taken care of my own finances,home ,job, well being,and happiness,and i done a very good job of it .I am in no debt to anyone but i am helping my son out of his debt [it,s what mothers do] I don,t need a man but i want one to love and to be my equal.Yes it,s important to me that he works and dones his bit because i am though with all the losers i have had in the past -what if i don,t find him Fine no big deal i stay on my own.

33

Dave

16 July 2011 19:02

Wow, so much bitterness! I agree that looks are what draws us to each other in the beginning but they never provide a solid foundation for a lasting relationship. Being financially responsible is of no interest to me when looking at matches, how my partner manages her finances has nothing to do with me and I would tend to avoid ones that have it as a priority. Well done you know how to budget and save, shouldn’t everyone?

The comment about the expensive aftershave made me laugh. Reminded me of the story of the guy who tried to sue lynx aftershaves as he hadn’t had a date in so many years after the ad told him all he needed was the aftershave. Im sure if your worst nightmare of a male slapped on some stupidly expensive aftershave, you wouldn’t fall into bed with him just because he smelt nice!

34

Teresa

16 July 2011 22:39

and i stick up my own selves, do my own decorating and Tiling.

35

tanith

19 July 2011 06:00

Heh, for everyone who sees an attribute as a negative, there will be someone who sees it as the opposite – whether that’s weight, financial status or whatever. Personally, to go back OT, I like men who get angry and shout and rant and rave. Can’t stand meek and mild who seem not to care about anything. Someone else mentioned not liking vain men – personally, the more vain the better! After all, they (hopefully!) know themselves better than anyone, and if they don’t think they’re absolutely fantastic, and enjoy making themselves as beautiful as they can be, then why on earth should I?
Just as well we’re not all after the same thing, or a few folk would be having a great time while the rest of us sat home alone

36

Mike

28 August 2011 12:27

Does nobody have anything positive to say? I am reading this and losing the will to live.

37

sonia

5 September 2011 21:50

hmmmm very interesting insights from those telling others how they should or shouldnt be, what they should or shouldnt of written in profiles, dont do this and dont do that or do that and you dont have a brain even though your still single. jeez lol

38

Shell

9 September 2011 12:19

I am obviously not feeling in a deep and pensive mood regarding the, what seems to be the difficult dating scene of today. Thanks everyone for all of your comments, some of them have certainly given me a giggle, intentional or not. I just think you have to feel comfortable with some one when you are out and about. Fat or thin, bald or hairy – no point in dating someone if you want to hide when you are with them when you spot a friend across the room. Everyone has different opinions and not all right or all wrong. Some men do have unrealistic expectations, but then again they are male with hormones, bless them! so what do you expect. Everybody will be laughing at my misfortunes no doubt at some point in the future, but I have not as yet taken the plunge and subscribed. Oh heck, dating was not this difficult when I was little (young that is, not meaning I have put weight on).

39

Joanne

1 October 2011 06:20

The only truth about attraction is the Latin phrase ‘Amor Omnia vincit’- Love Conquers all, regardless of size, age, wealth, race etc. At the end of the day true love is what we are all looking for….. right?

40

StJude

29 October 2011 21:30

It’s a truism that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. It is equally true that very rich men seldom seem to date, (by generally accepted standards) ‘ugly’ women. So, beauty is in the eye of the beholder but if you have a sizeable bank balance you can distort perception….

41

Ryan

12 November 2011 17:15

There MAY be logic behind the idea that overweight people are lazy and though hard, it is possible to change our weight. But how can people justify judging others on their height, skin tone or the shape of their face (Tall dark and handsome)? None of us choose the body we are born in (not unless we can afford surgery) yet it seems that a lot of people judge a person solely on that. It’s quite sad really.

42

poxycec

30 November 2011 20:26

I’d been wondering about this – as with all of us the notifications you blokes get will be showing my name, my location and my age (50). I have a nice, realistic profile pic. According to the ‘your activity’ bit, it’s rare that a man under 55 even looks at my profile. Obviously I don’t know how it’s working with ref to what groups of women pay interest to what groups of men, but it does seem to me that men are making assumptions about me purely on the basis of my age and their own hopes and dreams… In my real life I’m always taken for a good 10 years or so younger, so naturally I feel it’s a bit unfair, to say the least!

43

Emma

24 January 2012 21:33

Personally I don’t go for just looks in a man or how much money or what job he does etc.

I just want a nice, kind man who will treat me right. I have not had a lot of good relationships in the past so want someone who will be decent, loving and kind. Someone who enjoys some of the same interests. I don’t care if he has a small paunch on him, I like a little bit, better than being too skinny.

The most important thing is chemistry.

44

Kevin

18 February 2012 06:44

Certain people prefer different things when it comes to relationships but in the end we all want the same thing, to be loved and be happy. Its how we pursue what we want that makes us different

45

Sue

4 March 2012 23:57

Many of these comments are not a good advert for a dating agency!. I think there are basically 2 ways to fall for someone, they are physically attractive to you and set your heart pounding or they get more beautiful as you get to know them . But then beauty is in the eye of the beholder and different for everyone how many times do you finish a relationship and think ‘I don’t even find him attractive now’.

46

thepeacehappiness

13 August 2012 15:09

well to gold diggers old rich overweight men look very young and attractive.

47

Modesta Becvar

19 August 2012 16:13

The inner feelings that rule the choices in your daily life

48

Helen

5 April 2013 09:39

WOW, listen to you all, we are all individuals with different tastes, beauty is in the eye of the beholder and as people we all like different things, have different values and morals, does on line dating work? well people can be anything they want to be behind a computer, even fake pictures, so unless you take it into the real world and turn the first few pages of their book, you will never know….

49

Singleton

15 April 2013 11:54

What do women want???

Whatever it is, I’m not it, I’ve sadly discovered :-(

50

Andy

17 April 2013 20:29

Genuinely I think there’s a case here of people judging the article based upon their own personal experiences, rather than objectively. Attraction can take many forms as is evident in everyday life, so to believe there is always an agenda or like for like attraction aspect, would be to dismiss how another person can effect you through humor, music, and most importantly personality and how these things can shape how attractive a person is to you.

51

Michael

24 April 2013 19:39

Having read all 50 responses above many respondents above have valid points. I like two comments especially, by Emma (no.43) and Andy (no.50) who both make a lot of sense. I am certain that almost all well balanced people – regardless of age, wealth, looks or gender – crave both having someone to love and being loved just as much back. It’s in our genes. We’re all hard-wired and compelled to feel this way.
The issue is that so many people, for whatever reason don’t find or perhaps lose their ideal mate. So many things might not match between one’s desires and the realities found in a partner. Relationships are incredibly complex even at the best of times. As a starting point if you try to take good care of yourself, you are giving yourself the best chance of being attractive to another. Do the right things with them – being caring, fun, showing consideration and never forgetting a partner can be taken for granted, and that they too aren’t there to take liberties with either – you give yourself a great chance of any relationship working well.
My ‘issue’ is that though I tend to find women and have a lot going for me (in terms of the discussion above) but I feel often down fearing I’ll lose my partner and that’s hard on anyone with me. Before being criticized sharply about insecurity I’m talking of bereavements, which are damaging when you lose people you love. I don’t know what the solution is, or even if there is one. If anyone out there has sensible suggestions I’d appreciate reading them.

Comment on this article (no need to sign in)